Coaching Myths
Intended Audience: Everyone
Why Bust This Myth?
Recently, I was perusing one of my favorite online bowling discussion sites. There was a topic started by a bowler who was returning to bowling after a 5-6 year absence. The bowler had success with a coach in the past and was contemplating using a coach again.
The first 6 replies to the post can be summarized as follows: you don't need a coach. Each response gave a different reason why a bowler doesn't need a coach. While "you don't need a coach" can be a valid statement, the reasons given in the responses to this particular post were a bunch of myths.
I respect that the replies only intended to help. However, the reasoning behind the replies was flawed. There are probably thousands of other bowlers out there who have considered coaching for any number of reasons. The concept is not limited to bowling.
Myth: Elite Bowlers Don't Use Coaches
This statement is often heard from self-proclaimed "elite" bowlers. It's a load of manure. There seems to be a stigma in modern culture that if you seek help from another person it somehow makes you inferior, week, or somehow lacking. That is also a load of manure. Everyone needs help at one time or another. Bowlers are no different.
To debunk the myth, let's start at the top with the Professional Bowlers Association (PBA) professionals. People seem to think that these highly skilled and highly successful players don't need the help of a coach. At the very least, people seem to think that these top players may have used a coach in the past, but they don't need a coach anymore.
The fact is that most of the top professionals regularly seek the help of a coach.
We hear it right from the players' mouths. Witness the number of times on a PBA telecast that the winner looks directly into the camera and thanks his/her coach; the same coach the telecast commentators talk about helping the winner get his/her game back on track. I've had the forture to personally interact with several of the currently exempt PBA members and have talked to each about their practice and coaching schedules.
We also hear it from the coaches. Consider John Jowdy, the only coach (thus far) inducted into both the USBC and PBA Hall of Fame. In his book, Bowling Execution, Coach Jowdy talks about helping a large number of top-level professionals over the years while they're out on tour. There's also Doctor Dean Hinitz. He is generally considered the grandfather of bowling psychology. The proloague of his book "Focused for Bowling" is written by Brian Voss, a PBA Hall of Famer. In the prologue Mr. Voss describes at length how much help he has received and how grateful he is for getting that help from coach Hinitz. Two of North America's top coaches, Len Mal and Ron Clifton, have both described to me coaching sessions they've had with top professional bowlers. Another top coach, Mike Jasnau, has videotaped lessons with top professionals.
We read about it in bowling publications. US Bowler magazine consistently mentions coaching and training regimens for the top bowling schools such as Wichita State as well as for the national teams like Team USA. Bowling This Month magazine features articles that discuss problems the pros have overcome and how they were overcome with the help of good coaching.
Why do the best bowlers in the world take lessons? Like everyone else, top players experience slumps and down times in performance. They know where to get help when they need it. The "I'm a tough guy, I don't need help" mentality did not get these players to the top and doesn't factor into their continued success.
It amazes me that there are self-proclaimed "elite" bowlers who believe themselves to be better than the top professionals simply by not needing a coach. Maybe that's why we never see those self-proclaimed "elite" bowlers competing for a major title or making a living bowling.
Myth: The Best Bowlers Fix Themselves
Without a doubt, the best bowlers can fix what they are doing wrong. They do it on a daily basis, making the correct physical and mental adjustments to their game. However, even the best bowlers fall into slumps or at least have periods where they struggle more than others. Why? Because they miss something that starts to go wrong, they depart from the path of bowling success down a detour to troubled performance. To understand that, one must understand what causes a slump.
A slump is caused by doing something consistently wrong over a period of time. Most often it is something small that creeps into our game at an abnormal time. Maybe we've strained our sliding leg and favor it slightly by decreasing knee bend at the line. Left unnoticed, over time this small flaw can grow into a larger flaw: we decrease the knee bend a little more and a little more until our balance at the line suffers. That's simple enough to understand. Slumps are ended when the problem is corrected or overcome. That's also simple enough to understand. So why do the best bowlers, if they can self-diagnose and correct, have slumps? It's because they miss a flaw that creeps into their game and become a larger and larger problem over time as it affects other parts of their game.
If a bowler is regularly observed by a coach's trained eye, minor flaws can be caught before they develop into major flaws resulting in a slump. Even a bowling friend who is familiar with another bowler's game can keep an eye out for changes. However, will that friend also know how to fix the problem? Maybe, maybe not. Which leads us to the next myth.
As an aside, even a friend who just "helps out" from time to time in a productive fashion can be considered a coach. Maybe not a professional coach, but does it matter more that the help is successful or does the status of the source matter more?
Myth: All You Need is a Video Camera
A video camera represents an unbiased view of a bowler's mechanics. They are valuable tools in spotting problems in a bowler's physical mechanics especially since they can be played in slow-motion and freeze-framed to isolate specific incidents. With the cost of video camera constantly decreasing, more bowlers are able to use the technology to advantage. They are doubtless a huge help in spotting one or more problems.
It is often suggested to keep video of a bowler when the bowler is bowling well. It can then be compared to video taken when the bowler is not bowling well. That's good advice. It should be easier to spot when the bowler is doing something wrong. The operative phrase is "should be". The person watching the video tape must know what to look for and must be able to recognize differences that could result in poor performance versus better performance. Just because there is something different observed in the current video when compared to the video taken when the bowler is bowling well doesn't mean the something different is causing bad results.
Few bowlers spend much time watching and correcting other bowlers' games. Because of that, few bowlers have a coaches trained eye to diagnose a problem when it is seen and identify the root cause. Also, many bowlers will simply not be honest enough with themselves to admit a flaw when they see it. A coach has no interest in lying to a student about something that is wrong. The coach has less emotional attachment to a student's game than the student, so the coach can be more unbiased.
Consider an exception: the bowler in question is capable of spotting what is truly wrong, honest with him/herself that there is a problem, and can identify the root cause. Wonderful. Fantastic. Now what? The bowler knows what is wrong. Assume for a moment it is a new bad habit, one that the bowler has never dealt with before. How does that bowler fix it? They've never been able to do it in the past because they've never done it in the past. What is the best and quickest way to overcome the problem? Trial and error? That will work over time, but what if another new bad habit is acquired while attempting to fix the original flaw? Would you go to a surgeon who operated like that? "I don't know what's actually involved with removing a brain tumor Mr. Smith, but I'm willing to give it a whirl with this hacksaw and plunger over here." I don't think so.
Good coaches typically work with a range of students who have a wide variety of challenges to overcome. Coaches gain experience in helping different people fix different problems with different solutions. It is easy enough to understand that what works for one person doesn't necessarily work for another. So not only can coaches observe and recognize problems faster, they can help the bowler fix the problems faster.
There's one other point to make here: a video camera tells us nothing about what is going on in the bowler's head. A bowler can execute one shot and fall on his face while focusing on a flawless swing, perfect release, and smooth delivery. The same bowler can execute a shot while focusing on a flawless swing, perfect release, and smooth delivery and fall on his face while thinking about a chocolate chip ice cream cone. Both shots look identical to a video camera.
Coaches also help with the mental game. Things like positive visualization, confidence, and staying in the moment are concepts as foreign to a video camera as the concepts of astrophysics is to a rhinoceros.
Myth: All Coaches are the Same
"Coaches just want to change you."
"Coaches want you to do something different."
"Coaches want to fit you into a mold."
We often hear these statements made about coaches. Why?
Consider a patient who complains to his doctor of daily headaches. As the doctor delves into the patient's background, the doctor finds out that the patient has a habit of snorting airplane glue for a couple of hours every day. After some tests, the doctor is able to determine that the headaches are being caused by the glue. Should the doctor recommend the patient take a few aspirin every day or recommend that the patient stop snorting airplane glue?
Of course coaches want their students to change things. A fear of change is understandable. Most of us fear change at some level. However, change is the only way a student improves. When someone persists in doing something the same way over and over and expects a different result, we generally label that person "insane". To quote PBA member Robert Smith, aka "Maximum Bob" from an article in Bowling This Month magazine, "If you want to improve, you must be willing to change." Continuing to snort the glue isn't going to cure the headaches; neither is not taking the aspirin.
Good coaches understand that the key to good performance in bowling is repetition. A good coach is not going to suggest a change for something that is working for the student - something that the student can repeat over and over. There is room for improvement for everyone: at the very least, small things that could be better or things that make it difficult for the bowler to repeat over and over from start to finish. It is in that space that good coach will suggest changes.
Notice the repetition of the word good. Not all coaches are created equal. Some are more adept at working with beginning bowlers. Others are more adept at working with advanced bowlers. Finding a good coach is a completely separate article. The point that needs to be made is this: don't just all coaches from the experience with one or two bad coaches. Like bowlers, they are not all the same. Each bowler must find a coach who can relate things in a way that the bowler can understand, encourage the bowler to improve in a positive fashion, and provide positive corrective measures to help the bowler improve. Not every coach can help every bowler.
It should be mentioned that a coach can not and should not always be judged by his/her students. Each student has a different level of "coachability". Like the original example, some students will just take the aspirin and others will stop snorting the glue. The person taking the aspirin, so to speak, is not likely to make the coach look good or recommend the coach to others.
Conclusion
There are many myths that surround coaching most of which are related to our common fear of change. When looked at individually, these myths don't stand up to closer inspection.
Coaches offer an trained, knowledgeable, external point of view that can not only recognize a problem but identify the root cause of a problem and suggest solutions. They understand that there is no "one size fits all" solution, that each bowler is different, and what works for one bowler might not work for another. A good coach will treat each bowler uniquely, tailoring improvements to the bowler. Coaches also help improve a bowler's mental game, something that can't be seen on a video camera. True "elite" bowlers continue to use coaches to avoid slumps and as a shortcut to success.
While it is difficult to generalize and say "every bowler needs a coach" it is at least equally wrong to say "no one needs a coach".
Bowl well!
Showing posts with label coaching. Show all posts
Showing posts with label coaching. Show all posts
Monday, June 22, 2009
Tuesday, December 30, 2008
Why ask Why? Evaluating Internet Bowling Resources
Intended Audience: All readers
The only thing worse than bad information is wrong information.
As I become more aware of the number of bowling resources available on the Internet today, I'm constantly surprised and frustrated by the amount of information available that is:
Confusing Information
Earlier today, I was watching an instructional bowling video that was published on the Internet via YouTube. On it the instructor is speaking about timing. He notes that timing is a "major thing" in bowling. This is true. However, he says it is a "major thing once you get set in your stance". He then goes on to say that it is the "timing of the ball to the approach and the swing".
Huh?
Once you're "set in your stance" you're just standing there, hopefully with nothing moving, otherwise you're not "set". There's no timing involved with one's stance.
"Approach" is not explained as the bowler's movement to the foul line or the physical area of the lane under the bowler's feet behind the foul line. It would have been better to say "footwork" or "movement to the foul line".
I would certainly hope the ball is somehow involved in the swing, since the ball moves with the hand, wrist, elbow, arm, and shoulder. How does that relate to timing, which is stated as a "major thing"? There are no clarifying remarks later in the video which gets even more confusing as it goes on.
I think coaches are great especially coaches like this one who are willing to impart their knowledge free of charge and for no reason other than helping others to become better bowlers. However, if your message is confusing, it isn't going to help anyone and you've wasted your time and potentially wasted the time of the aspiring bowler.
In defense of the author of this video, it appears that he's attempting to keep his lessons short and to the point. That's a good goal, but it leads to another problem.
Incomplete Information
On many bowling sites there is well-worn and often posted equipment advice for competing on sport conditions. To paraphrase much of the advice available:
"You want something controllable"
"Use control equipment, not league equipment."
"Don't use any skid-flip or skid-snap equipment."
Ok. Great. But why?
I seldom see the explanation of why attached. Also, if the bowler is an intermediate bowler, there are also more unanswered questions. What is control equipment? What is league equipment? What is skid-flip or skid-snap equipment? Why wouldn't I be able to control the ball I'm throwing, am I not the one throwing it?
Give a man a fish and feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish and feed him for a life time.
I'll admit to being a "why person" and I understand that not everyone is like me. However, there are going to be enough "why people" reading the general Internet that it is best to include the explanation whenever possible. If one does not truly understand the why and/or can not explain the why, they shouldn't be posting any advice on that topic until they do. Teachers need to be at a higher level of understanding than their students at the beginning of the teaching process.
If the article or post or video clearly states that the article or advice is geared towards advanced bowlers who presumably know the answers to these latter questions, that's one thing. Otherwise, we have another problem.
Information Directed at the Wrong Audience
When I stop to think about it, there is a huge amount of bowling slang and technical jargon in common use today. We bowlers tend to throw that slang and jargon around without a second thought and often times without regard for our listeners. People are often afraid to ask "what do you mean by slang-term?" or in the case of Internet sites, people often aren't given the tools/options to ask the question.
Web-based bowling sites are rife with slang and advice full of terminology that means nothing to the beginning bowler. This is often true even when the advice is written "for beginners". While one may want to lump this into the "Confusing Information" category, there's a subtle difference that is important. When a group of people are using language we don't understand, it can cause us to feel like an outsider, like we don't belong. That's hardly an environment we want to create for new bowlers especially if we're trying to help them.
The same can be said for advanced concepts addressed to intermediate bowlers. Trust me, there are advanced bowlers who don't understand the concept of a PSA (preferred spin axis) and spin time, let alone the intermediate bowlers.
If we consistently speak "above" our target audience's level of knowledge, we should expect that audience to go elsewhere for the information or worse, give up seeking the information. At that point, we've once again wasted our time and our target audience's time.
Bowlers are generally not astro-physicists or rocket scientists. The business adage to write at the sixth grade level is a good idea. It virtually ensures that every audience will understand you.
But wait, there's more... I'm violating my own rules!
I apologize to my english-speaking audience residing outside of the United States and Canada. I'm not sure how the sixth grade level in the United States equates to the school systems in other countries. Roughly speaking, it is 3 school years of english after basic phonics.
Incorrect Information
As the saying goes, the way to hell is paved with good intentions.
There is much information out there on the Internet that is just incorrect, simply wrong. For example, the other day on a bowling site I saw advice on how to make a bowling ball go longer down the lane and hook harder on the back end (the part of the lane closer to the pins). The advice said to use a dull particle ball.
**buzzer** Nope, try again.
It is possible that the person offering the advice was trying to give bad advice, but for the sake of this discussion I will assume that is never the case. People who purposely give incorrect information are outside the scope of this topic.
Some people mean well but just don't know any better. People looking for help certainly don't know any better or else they wouldn't be looking for help! Unfortunately, for many information seekers, they can't distinguish between the people who mean well but don't have the correct information and the people who mean well and who do have the correct information.
I've even experienced "certified" coaches giving out incorrect information. Am I saying that I know more than they do? Most of the time, no, but I can read the USBC rule book to find out what constitutes a legal delivery. If it is at odds with the instructor, who is correct, the instructor or the governing body of bowling in the United States? At other times yes, I do know more than a "certified" coash. I have the first-hand experience that the some coaches do not have or I have the knowledge imparted to me by others who have the hands-on experience. At still other times, I have and understand the science.
As previously mentioned, it is the understanding of the why and the ability to effectively communicate the why that is so important.
Who to Believe?
Earlier I mentioned YouTube as a source of an instructional bowling video. It should be noted that just because YouTube is not a bowling site and contains many silly videos, that doesn't automatically disqualify YouTube as a source for good instructional bowling videos. Each piece of information should be evaluated based on its content, not the web site on which the content is posted.
On the flip side of that coin, just because a piece of advice or an instructional article is posted on a reputable bowling site doesn't mean that the information is clear, concise, and correct. Again, each piece of information should be evaluated based on its content. It is true that reputable sites dedicated to bowling will generally have better content, but that doesn't mean every article is a good article.
The same is true for people. Beware of evaluating advice solely on the person giving the advice. That's known as an ad hominem logic fallacy. Just because a bowler has a low average doesn't mean they don't understand bowling concepts and certainly doesn't mean that low average bowlers can't teach you anything. The reverse is also true. Just because a "big name" or a high average bowler says something is so, doesn't make it true. Ask them to explain the why in terms you can understand. If they can't do so, you can and should seek other opinions.
Moving Forward
By all means, you can and should use the comment section of this site to call me out when I violate my own rules. I'm human and make mistakes just like everyone else. I welcome the opportunity to learn and improve from you. I firmly believe that any two human beings of roughly the same age have the same amount or sum of knowledge. It is the areas of knowledge that are different. We can all learn from one another if we just take the time to do so.
The only thing worse than bad information is wrong information.
As I become more aware of the number of bowling resources available on the Internet today, I'm constantly surprised and frustrated by the amount of information available that is:
- Confusing
- Incomplete
- Directed at the wrong audience
- Incorrect - often blatantly
Confusing Information
Earlier today, I was watching an instructional bowling video that was published on the Internet via YouTube. On it the instructor is speaking about timing. He notes that timing is a "major thing" in bowling. This is true. However, he says it is a "major thing once you get set in your stance". He then goes on to say that it is the "timing of the ball to the approach and the swing".
Huh?
Once you're "set in your stance" you're just standing there, hopefully with nothing moving, otherwise you're not "set". There's no timing involved with one's stance.
"Approach" is not explained as the bowler's movement to the foul line or the physical area of the lane under the bowler's feet behind the foul line. It would have been better to say "footwork" or "movement to the foul line".
I would certainly hope the ball is somehow involved in the swing, since the ball moves with the hand, wrist, elbow, arm, and shoulder. How does that relate to timing, which is stated as a "major thing"? There are no clarifying remarks later in the video which gets even more confusing as it goes on.
I think coaches are great especially coaches like this one who are willing to impart their knowledge free of charge and for no reason other than helping others to become better bowlers. However, if your message is confusing, it isn't going to help anyone and you've wasted your time and potentially wasted the time of the aspiring bowler.
In defense of the author of this video, it appears that he's attempting to keep his lessons short and to the point. That's a good goal, but it leads to another problem.
Incomplete Information
On many bowling sites there is well-worn and often posted equipment advice for competing on sport conditions. To paraphrase much of the advice available:
"You want something controllable"
"Use control equipment, not league equipment."
"Don't use any skid-flip or skid-snap equipment."
Ok. Great. But why?
I seldom see the explanation of why attached. Also, if the bowler is an intermediate bowler, there are also more unanswered questions. What is control equipment? What is league equipment? What is skid-flip or skid-snap equipment? Why wouldn't I be able to control the ball I'm throwing, am I not the one throwing it?
Give a man a fish and feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish and feed him for a life time.
I'll admit to being a "why person" and I understand that not everyone is like me. However, there are going to be enough "why people" reading the general Internet that it is best to include the explanation whenever possible. If one does not truly understand the why and/or can not explain the why, they shouldn't be posting any advice on that topic until they do. Teachers need to be at a higher level of understanding than their students at the beginning of the teaching process.
If the article or post or video clearly states that the article or advice is geared towards advanced bowlers who presumably know the answers to these latter questions, that's one thing. Otherwise, we have another problem.
Information Directed at the Wrong Audience
When I stop to think about it, there is a huge amount of bowling slang and technical jargon in common use today. We bowlers tend to throw that slang and jargon around without a second thought and often times without regard for our listeners. People are often afraid to ask "what do you mean by slang-term?" or in the case of Internet sites, people often aren't given the tools/options to ask the question.
Web-based bowling sites are rife with slang and advice full of terminology that means nothing to the beginning bowler. This is often true even when the advice is written "for beginners". While one may want to lump this into the "Confusing Information" category, there's a subtle difference that is important. When a group of people are using language we don't understand, it can cause us to feel like an outsider, like we don't belong. That's hardly an environment we want to create for new bowlers especially if we're trying to help them.
The same can be said for advanced concepts addressed to intermediate bowlers. Trust me, there are advanced bowlers who don't understand the concept of a PSA (preferred spin axis) and spin time, let alone the intermediate bowlers.
If we consistently speak "above" our target audience's level of knowledge, we should expect that audience to go elsewhere for the information or worse, give up seeking the information. At that point, we've once again wasted our time and our target audience's time.
Bowlers are generally not astro-physicists or rocket scientists. The business adage to write at the sixth grade level is a good idea. It virtually ensures that every audience will understand you.
But wait, there's more... I'm violating my own rules!
I apologize to my english-speaking audience residing outside of the United States and Canada. I'm not sure how the sixth grade level in the United States equates to the school systems in other countries. Roughly speaking, it is 3 school years of english after basic phonics.
Incorrect Information
As the saying goes, the way to hell is paved with good intentions.
There is much information out there on the Internet that is just incorrect, simply wrong. For example, the other day on a bowling site I saw advice on how to make a bowling ball go longer down the lane and hook harder on the back end (the part of the lane closer to the pins). The advice said to use a dull particle ball.
**buzzer** Nope, try again.
It is possible that the person offering the advice was trying to give bad advice, but for the sake of this discussion I will assume that is never the case. People who purposely give incorrect information are outside the scope of this topic.
Some people mean well but just don't know any better. People looking for help certainly don't know any better or else they wouldn't be looking for help! Unfortunately, for many information seekers, they can't distinguish between the people who mean well but don't have the correct information and the people who mean well and who do have the correct information.
I've even experienced "certified" coaches giving out incorrect information. Am I saying that I know more than they do? Most of the time, no, but I can read the USBC rule book to find out what constitutes a legal delivery. If it is at odds with the instructor, who is correct, the instructor or the governing body of bowling in the United States? At other times yes, I do know more than a "certified" coash. I have the first-hand experience that the some coaches do not have or I have the knowledge imparted to me by others who have the hands-on experience. At still other times, I have and understand the science.
As previously mentioned, it is the understanding of the why and the ability to effectively communicate the why that is so important.
Who to Believe?
Earlier I mentioned YouTube as a source of an instructional bowling video. It should be noted that just because YouTube is not a bowling site and contains many silly videos, that doesn't automatically disqualify YouTube as a source for good instructional bowling videos. Each piece of information should be evaluated based on its content, not the web site on which the content is posted.
On the flip side of that coin, just because a piece of advice or an instructional article is posted on a reputable bowling site doesn't mean that the information is clear, concise, and correct. Again, each piece of information should be evaluated based on its content. It is true that reputable sites dedicated to bowling will generally have better content, but that doesn't mean every article is a good article.
The same is true for people. Beware of evaluating advice solely on the person giving the advice. That's known as an ad hominem logic fallacy. Just because a bowler has a low average doesn't mean they don't understand bowling concepts and certainly doesn't mean that low average bowlers can't teach you anything. The reverse is also true. Just because a "big name" or a high average bowler says something is so, doesn't make it true. Ask them to explain the why in terms you can understand. If they can't do so, you can and should seek other opinions.
Moving Forward
By all means, you can and should use the comment section of this site to call me out when I violate my own rules. I'm human and make mistakes just like everyone else. I welcome the opportunity to learn and improve from you. I firmly believe that any two human beings of roughly the same age have the same amount or sum of knowledge. It is the areas of knowledge that are different. We can all learn from one another if we just take the time to do so.
Labels:
advanced,
advice,
article,
beginner,
bowling,
coach,
coaching,
help,
information,
instruction,
intermediate,
logic,
tips,
video,
why
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)